Italian compromesso: how the deposit works and what you risk
The Italian preliminary contract binds both sides. How the caparra works, what registration costs, and when transcription or annotation protects you.
The compromesso is the preliminary contract of sale (contratto preliminare). It binds you and the seller to sign the final deed, the rogito, at a price and on a date you agree now. The deposit you pay with it is usually a caparra confirmatoria: if you break the deal you lose it, and if the seller breaks it you can claim double (article 1385 of the Civil Code). The preliminary must be registered with the tax office within 30 days. It can also be recorded against the property, and in Trieste that means an annotation in the Libro fondiario, not a transcription.
In short
- The deposit: under article 1385 the seller keeps a caparra confirmatoria if you are in breach, and you can demand double if the seller is. The right to withdraw presupposes a breach, and the breach must be serious.
- The label: the contract should say whether a sum is a caparra confirmatoria, a caparra penitenziale (article 1386) or an acconto, a part-payment of the price. The three work differently.
- The form: the preliminary needs the same form as the final contract (article 1351). For a home, that is in writing.
- The registration: within 30 days, with a fixed tax of €200 plus stamp duty, and 0.5% on a caparra confirmatoria.
- The protection: against the seller's later sale or mortgage, the remedy is a transcription (article 2645-bis). It needs a notary. In Trieste it is an annotation instead.
- The mortgage: the cover is a mortgage condition written into the contract (article 1353).
- The price: either party can ask the notary to hold it until the deed is registered and published (law 147/2013, article 1, paragraph 63).
How does the compromesso differ from the offer?
Before it you will usually have signed a proposta d'acquisto, a written offer, often on the agency's printed form. According to the Consiglio Nazionale del Notariato, the proposal binds only the person who signs it, and the seller can consider other offers meanwhile. You may change your mind until the seller accepts, unless you made the proposal irrevocable for a stated period: during that period a revocation has no effect (article 1329). The contract is concluded at the moment the seller's acceptance comes to your knowledge (article 1326).
Read that last point twice. The Notariato says that when the seller signs, the preliminary is in effect concluded, on the clauses of the printed form. A new and more detailed compromesso can replace it only if both sides agree. If they do not, you either withdraw (losing the caparra, or returning double if you are the seller) or stay bound to the proposal. So put what matters in the proposal: the mortgage condition, the payment dates, what is sold with the home.
What must the preliminary look like?
It must take the same form that the law requires for the final contract, or it is void (article 1351). For a home that means in writing: a private writing, a private writing authenticated by a notary, or a notarial deed. A notary is compulsory only in some cases, for example a home not yet built, which a builder sells to a private buyer (see buying off-plan in Italy).
What happens to my deposit if the deal falls through?
Article 1385 sets the rule for a caparra confirmatoria, the sum one party gives the other when the contract is concluded.
- If you gave the caparra and you are in breach, the seller may withdraw and keep it.
- If the seller received it and is in breach, you may withdraw and demand double.
- If the deal is completed, the caparra is returned or counted towards the price.
Example: price €300,000, caparra €30,000. If you default, the seller keeps €30,000. If the seller defaults, you can claim €60,000, which is double the caparra.
Three limits. The right depends on a breach by the other side, and the Constitutional Court recalls that the breach must be seriously culpable: attributable to the party and of not slight importance (order 248/2013). Second, withdrawal works as self-help: you do not need a judgment first (Brocardi's annotations to article 1385, citing Supreme Court rulings). Third, you choose. The party in the right can instead ask a court for performance or for termination, and then damages follow the general rules (article 1385, third paragraph). The Notariato adds that, according to case law, you cannot combine the caparra with a claim for greater damages.
| What it is | If the buyer is in breach | If the seller is in breach | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Caparra confirmatoria (art. 1385) | Security given when the contract is concluded | Seller may withdraw and keep it | Buyer may withdraw and demand double |
| Caparra penitenziale (art. 1386) | The price of a right to withdraw written into the contract | A buyer who withdraws loses it | A seller who withdraws returns double |
| Acconto | Part-payment of the price | Doubling is provided for the caparra (arts. 1385-1386) | Doubling is provided for the caparra (arts. 1385-1386) |
The wording decides which one you have. The Agenzia delle Entrate says that if the contract does not state why a sum was paid, the sum counts as an acconto. Ask for the label to be written beside every payment.
What if the seller will not sign the deed?
Article 2932 allows a court to step in. If the party bound to conclude a contract does not, the other party can obtain a judgment that produces the effects of the contract not concluded, where that is possible and the contract does not exclude it. For a sale of property you must have performed your own side, which means paying the price, or offered to in the way the law provides, unless the payment is not yet due.
It is an alternative to termination and damages. The Notariato notes that it may be impossible in practice, for example when the home was sold to a third party and your preliminary was not transcribed.
Do I have to register the compromesso, and what does it cost?
Yes. The Agenzia delle Entrate gives 30 days from the signature for registration, which is compulsory. The costs:
- registration tax: a fixed €200, whatever the price;
- stamp duty: €16 for every four pages (the Agency's 2024 guide gives €155 if the preliminary is a notarial deed or an authenticated writing);
- 0.5% on a caparra confirmatoria, or the lower tax that would apply to the final deed;
- the same 0.5% on advances of the price not subject to VAT;
- 3% on a caparra penitenziale.
If the sale carries VAT, as with a builder, advances are invoiced with VAT and bear the fixed tax instead. A caparra confirmatoria stays outside VAT and bears the 0.5%. The Agenzia's guide to buying a home (July 2024) shows 3% on advances and its current page on the registration form shows 0.5%. Check the rate at signing.
Example: caparra €30,000, no VAT. 0.5% is €150. With the fixed €200, you pay €350 plus stamp duty. The same guide says the tax paid on the preliminary is deducted from the registration tax due on the deed. For the full picture of costs, see purchase taxes in Italy: the honest numbers.
How do I protect myself if the seller sells again or borrows?
Without more, the preliminary binds only the two of you. The Notariato says the seller could still sell the home to someone else or register a mortgage on it, and you could then claim only damages.
The remedy is the transcription of the preliminary in the property registers. Under article 2645-bis, the transcription of the final deed, or of a judgment under article 2932, prevails over transcriptions and registrations, mortgages for example, made against the seller after the preliminary was transcribed. It needs a notarial deed or an authenticated writing. The Notariato says the notary who received or authenticated it does the transcription, within 30 days of signing.
The protection is not permanent. Its effects lapse if the final deed is not transcribed within one year of the date agreed for it, and in any case within three years of the transcription. The Notariato adds a second benefit: claims to be repaid your advances, or to double the caparra, gain a special privilege on the property.
The costs are a fixed transcription tax, fixed fees and the notary's fee. The Notariato suggests transcription is more worth it when:
- a long gap separates the preliminary from the deed;
- the sum you pay early is large;
- the seller is a business, which can become insolvent.
When a builder sells a private buyer a home that is not yet built, and the building permit was requested from 16 March 2019, transcription is compulsory.
And in Trieste?
There is no transcription in Trieste. Article 12 of royal decree no. 499 of 1929 disapplies chapters I and II of title I of book VI of the Civil Code where the land register law applies, with exceptions that include the preliminary of article 2645-bis, which is annotated instead (land register law, article 20, letter h). Ownership passes only on entry of the right in the Libro fondiario (article 2 of the same decree).
Once annotated, the land register judge orders the cancellation of incompatible entries that third parties obtained from the seller on applications filed after your application for annotation (land register law, article 60-ter). The same limits as above apply: the annotation is cancelled on request once its effects end (article 60-quater). For how the Libro fondiario works, see the Trieste land register.
What if my mortgage does not come through?
The cover is a written condition. Article 1353 lets the parties make the effects of a contract depend on a future, uncertain event, and the grant of your mortgage can be that event. The Court of Cassation classes it as a "mixed" condition, since it depends both on the bank and on your own application, and holds that when the loan is not granted the consequences are those the contract provides (judgment 22046/2019).
So the contract has to say what happens. Ask for the amount, the lender or lenders, and a deadline for the bank's answer to be written in, and for the same clause to appear in the proposal. For the lender's side, see mortgages in Italy for non-residents.
Can I stop the seller getting the money before the deed is registered?
Yes, if you ask. Under law 147/2013, article 1, paragraph 63, as replaced by law 124/2017, the notary must receive the whole price, or the balance, into a dedicated account when at least one party requests it. Under paragraph 66, the notary releases it once the deed is registered and published and no further encumbrances have appeared beyond those existing at the date of the deed or resulting from it. The sums are separate from the notary's own estate and cannot be seized (paragraph 65).
Raise the deposit with your notary before the deed: the seller is paid later than at the signing, after the notary's checks. For the signing itself, see signing the Italian deed if you don't speak Italian.
What should I do before I sign?
- Put the conditions in the proposal, not only in the compromesso.
- Name each payment: caparra confirmatoria, caparra penitenziale or acconto.
- Write the mortgage condition with amount, lender and deadline.
- Ask whether the preliminary will be notarial, and whether it will be transcribed or, in Trieste, annotated.
- Check who registers it and when. The deadline is 30 days.
- Decide early whether you will ask the notary to hold the price.
What this guide does not cover
It covers the preliminary between private parties. It does not cover builder guarantees, VAT on a developer's sale, or the tax regime of your own residence. Case law on serious breach and on mortgage conditions is not settled in every detail: ask your notary how your contract would be read.
If you are the seller, selling your Trieste home to a foreign buyer covers your side, and you can ask for a valuation.
General information, not legal advice; your notary has the final say on your own contract. Questions: richieste@triestevillas.com or WhatsApp +39 331 8940822.
Sources
- Codice civile, art. 1385 (Brocardi)
- Codice civile, art. 1386 (Brocardi)
- Codice civile, art. 1326 (Brocardi)
- Codice civile, art. 1329 (Brocardi)
- Codice civile, art. 1353 (Brocardi)
- Codice civile, art. 2645-bis (Brocardi)
- Codice civile, art. 2932 (Brocardi)
- Corte costituzionale, ordinanza 248/2013
- Agenzia delle Entrate, Contratto preliminare di compravendita (modello RAP)
- Agenzia delle Entrate, L'acquisto della casa: le imposte e le agevolazioni (luglio 2024)
- Consiglio Nazionale del Notariato, Garanzia preliminare (ed. marzo 2023)
- Legge 27 dicembre 2013, n. 147, art. 1, commi 63-67 (Normattiva)
- Legge 4 agosto 2017, n. 124, art. 1, comma 142 (testo della Gazzetta Ufficiale)
- Regio decreto 28 marzo 1929, n. 499, art. 12 (Normattiva)
- Legge tavolare, testo vigente (Regione FVG, agg. 2015): artt. 2, 20, 60-bis, 60-ter, 60-quater
- Legge tavolare, art. 60-ter (Normattiva)
- Regione FVG, I princìpi fondamentali del sistema tavolare
Written with AI and checked against the sources by the TriesteVillas editorial team. How we use AI →
This is an overview, not legal or tax advice: rules change and cases differ. Your notaio and commercialista have the final word — and TriesteVillas walks you through every stage in person. richieste@triestevillas.com · +39 331 8940822 (WhatsApp).
Looking for a home?
Homes in Trieste, Friuli-Venezia Giulia and across the border, with the real numbers on costs and taxes.